My Business Is Insolvent — What Are My Options?
Take a breath. You're not the first business owner to face this, and there are real options. This guide walks you through what to do right now, step by step.
Insolvency Does Not Mean Liquidation — You Have More Options Than You Think
Insolvency does not automatically mean liquidation. Since January 2021, over 6,000 Australian businesses have used Small Business Restructuring to reduce debts by 60-80% and keep trading. The key is acting quickly — the sooner you get advice, the more options remain open.
Australian Business Insolvency — Key Facts at a Glance
Four headline numbers that frame the scale of business insolvency in Australia and the personal-liability stakes for directors:
Australia-wide across all pathways (ASIC Series 1 & 2)
SBR now accounts for ~1 in 5 insolvency appointments
Under Section 588G of the Corporations Act
After which insolvency is presumed
6 Warning Signs Your Australian Business May Be Insolvent
The legal test is simple: can your company pay its debts as and when they fall due? If the answer is no, or you're not sure, these signs may confirm it.
Can't pay debts as they fall due
The legal test for insolvency in Australia. If you're juggling payments or robbing Peter to pay Paul, this may already apply.
Creditors are chasing you
Supplier calls, debt collector letters, or legal threats. Creditor pressure typically accelerates once one starts chasing.
ATO debt is growing
93% of SBR companies have ATO debt. Unpaid BAS, PAYG, or super is often the first sign of deeper cash flow problems.
Overdue BAS or super
Late lodgements can trigger Director Penalty Notices and lock you out of restructuring options.
Relying on new debt to pay old debt
Using credit cards, personal loans, or director loans to cover operating costs is a red flag.
Trading at a loss for months
If your P&L has been negative for 3+ months and there's no clear turnaround plan, the business may be insolvent.
If two or more of these apply to you
Your business may already be insolvent. This is not a judgement — it's a legal status with specific options and protections. The important thing is what you do next.
How Australian Law Defines Insolvency — Cash-Flow vs Balance-Sheet Tests
Australian insolvency law uses a primary cash-flow test (inability to pay debts as they fall due) and secondary indicators developed through case law. Understanding these tests matters because personal-liability rules under s 588G depend on when the company became insolvent.
Cash-flow test (primary)
Corporations Act s 95AThe primary legal test: a person is solvent if they can pay all their debts as and when they become due and payable. Failing this test is the most common legal finding of insolvency in Australian case law. Evidence includes juggling creditor payments, missed payroll, unpaid BAS, and reliance on new credit to pay existing debts.
Balance-sheet test (secondary)
General law / accounting principlesA company is considered balance-sheet insolvent if its liabilities exceed its assets at a point in time. This is a supporting indicator but not the primary legal test in Australia. A company can be technically balance-sheet insolvent yet still solvent in the cash-flow sense if it can access funding, refinance, or realise assets in time to pay debts as they fall due.
Indicators courts use
ASIC v Plymin and subsequent casesAustralian courts have identified indicators including: continuing losses, liquidity ratios below 1.0, overdue statutory obligations, inability to obtain finance, creditor pressure, incomplete financial records, and reliance on director loans or personal guarantees. Multiple indicators present together strongly suggest cash-flow insolvency.
Presumption of insolvency
Corporations Act s 459CIf a company fails to comply with a statutory demand within 21 days, it is presumed to be insolvent in any subsequent wind-up application. This presumption can be rebutted with evidence of solvency, but it is a difficult burden once the demand has expired.
Australian Business Insolvency Options Compared — SBR vs VA vs Liquidation vs Payment Plan vs Safe Harbour
Every situation is different. Here's an honest comparison of the five main pathways available to insolvent Australian businesses.
| Option | Cost | Debt Reduction | Director Control | Business Continues | Timeline |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Small Business Restructuring (SBR) Recommended | $15,000-$30,000 | 60-80% | 20 business days + 15 days voting | ||
| Voluntary Administration (VA) | $50,000+ | Varies | Maybe | 3-6 months | |
| Liquidation | $10,000-$30,000 | N/A (business closes) | 6-12 months | ||
| ATO Payment Plan | Free to arrange | None (pay 100%) | Days to arrange | ||
| Safe Harbour Protection | Advisory fees | None directly | Ongoing |
For most viable small businesses with debt under $1M, SBR offers the best balance of debt reduction, cost, and control.
The first decision is not "how do I save everything?" but "what outcome is still realistic?"
Insolvency triage works best when directors separate panic from facts. The practical goal is to stop personal risk from increasing, stabilise the cash picture, and decide quickly whether the business is genuinely viable with debt relief.
Protect the downside first
New debt, missed lodgements, and poor recordkeeping can make a hard situation materially worse.
Check whether the core business still works
If margins and demand remain viable, restructuring may still preserve the company.
Move before the options narrow
The earlier advice is taken, the more likely directors can use SBR or safe harbour effectively.
What to Do in the First 48 Hours After Discovering Insolvency
These six steps protect you personally and preserve the most options for your business.
Stop making the situation worse
Don't take on new debt, don't pay related parties ahead of other creditors, and don't sell assets below value. These actions can create personal liability.
Document everything from today
Start a written record of your financial position, decisions, and reasons. This protects you if insolvent trading is ever questioned.
Check your lodgements
Are your BAS, PAYG, and super lodgements up to date? Late lodgements can trigger lockdown DPNs and block SBR eligibility.
Build a complete debt picture
List every creditor, amount owed, and whether the debt is secured. Include ATO debt, suppliers, landlord, finance companies, and employee entitlements.
Prepare a 13-week cash flow
Map out your expected income and expenses for the next 13 weeks. This is the first thing any advisor will ask for.
Get professional advice within 48 hours
Speak with a restructuring practitioner or insolvency advisor, not just your regular accountant. Time is your most valuable asset right now.
The 48-hour rule: Most insolvency professionals say the difference between a good outcome and a bad one comes down to how quickly directors seek advice. Every week of delay reduces your options.
When Small Business Restructuring (SBR) Is Right for an Insolvent Business
SBR has helped thousands of Australian businesses survive insolvency. But it's not right for everyone. Here's an honest assessment.
SBR may be right if...
- Your business is viable but crushed by debt (especially ATO debt)
- Total debts are under $1 million
- You want to stay in control and keep trading
- Your tax lodgements are up to date (or can be caught up quickly)
- You can afford to pay 20-40% of your debts over time
- You haven't used SBR in the past 7 years
The ATO votes in favour of SBR plans over 90% of the time. SBR costs $15,000-$30,000 and takes approximately 20 business days.
SBR may NOT be right if...
- Your business has no viable path to profitability even without debt
- Total debts exceed $1 million (VA may be more appropriate)
- Your tax lodgements are severely behind and can't be caught up quickly
- You've already received a lockdown DPN
- The business model itself is broken, not just the balance sheet
- You want to close the business and move on (liquidation may be better)
Being honest about suitability saves time and money. A restructuring practitioner can assess your situation in an initial consultation.
Why SBR Works for Insolvent Businesses
SBR plans achieve high approval rates and preserve business continuity. The three structural reasons:
Per ASIC Report 810, 87% of SBR plans are approved by creditors and 93% of companies continue trading after the plan completes. The underlying reasons creditors accept SBR:
Better Return Than Liquidation
SBR plans deliver better creditor returns than liquidation on average. Creditors vote yes when they see meaningful recovery against a low-value liquidation alternative — the ATO approves over 90% of plans where it is a creditor.
Business Survives, Keeps Paying
A restructured business keeps trading, paying future taxes, and meeting ongoing obligations. Per ASIC Report 810, 93% of companies that complete an SBR plan continue trading afterwards — meaningful business continuity.
Directors Stay in Control
Unlike voluntary administration or liquidation, directors retain management control throughout SBR. This encourages directors to act early instead of waiting until options narrow — the policy intent of Part 5.3B.
SBR is designed for exactly this situation — insolvent but viable businesses with debts under $1M.
Director Duties, Insolvent Trading Liability (Section 588G) & Safe Harbour Protection
This is the part most business owners don't know about until it's too late. Understanding your personal exposure is critical.
Insolvent trading (Section 588G)
Directors who allow a company to incur debts while insolvent can be held personally liable. Penalties can include personal liability for the debts and fines up to $200,000.
Safe harbour protection (Section 588GA)
If you suspect insolvency, you can access safe harbour protection by developing a course of action reasonably likely to lead to a better outcome than liquidation. This requires proper advice and documentation.
Director Penalty Notices
The ATO can issue DPNs making directors personally liable for unpaid PAYG, super, and GST. You have 21 days to respond. Late lodgements can trigger lockdown DPNs with no restructuring options.
Duty to prevent insolvent trading
Once you suspect insolvency, continuing to trade without a plan or professional advice creates increasing personal risk. The earlier you act, the more protection options are available.
The safe harbour defence is your protection
Under Section 588GA of the Corporations Act, directors who suspect insolvency can access safe harbour protection by taking appropriate steps — like engaging a restructuring practitioner and developing a turnaround plan. This means acting now actually protects you, even if the business ultimately doesn't survive. Doing nothing is the riskiest option. Learn more about insolvent trading risks and Director Penalty Notices.
Voidable Transactions — Actions a Liquidator Can Reverse
Transactions entered into during or causing insolvency can be unwound by a liquidator. Recipients (including directors and related parties) can be ordered to repay amounts received — creating personal exposure long after the company is wound up.
Unfair Preference (s 588FA)
Look-back: 6 months (related party: 4 years)A payment or transfer to a creditor that gives them more than they would receive in a liquidation. The classic example: paying one supplier in full while leaving others unpaid when the company is insolvent. Liquidators can recover these payments from the recipient. Look-back runs from the appointment date.
Uncommercial Transaction (s 588FB)
Look-back: 2 years (related party: 4 years)A transaction that a reasonable person in the company's position would not have entered into, considering the benefits to the company, detriments, and respective benefits. Selling company assets below market value, forgiving related-party debts, or paying inflated prices to related entities are classic examples.
Unreasonable Director-Related Transaction (s 588FDA)
Look-back: 4 yearsA transaction with a director, close associate, or related entity that is unreasonable considering the benefit to the company and the detriment to creditors. This catches a wide range of director loans, drawings, asset transfers, and payments to related entities. Liquidators pursue these aggressively.
Insolvent Transaction (umbrella concept)
Look-back: Varies by sub-typeAn umbrella concept covering any transaction that was an unfair preference, uncommercial transaction, unreasonable director-related transaction, or unfair loan, entered into when the company was insolvent (or became insolvent as a result). The liquidator must establish the company's insolvency at the time of the transaction.
Insolvency Concerns Directors Raise Most — Addressed Directly
Seven high-stakes worries that commonly surface when directors face insolvency. Answers clarify the rules and personal-liability implications of each scenario.
What if I keep trading for just a few more weeks to see if cash flow improves?
This is the #1 mistake directors make. Trading while insolvent can create personal liability under Section 588G for every new debt incurred. "A few more weeks" often compounds the problem — more unpaid creditors, more ATO debt, more DPN exposure. The safer approach is to access safe harbour protection (s 588GA) while you develop a formal response. Safe harbour requires genuine turnaround plans and professional advice, not a "wait and see" strategy.
Can my bank freeze my accounts during insolvency?
Banks can restrict accounts where they detect insolvency signals (unpaid loans, default notices, security breaches), but they typically don't unilaterally freeze operating accounts without cause. Secured lenders can enforce security interests. The ATO can issue garnishee notices directing your bank to pay funds directly to the ATO. Proactive communication with your bank before distress escalates typically preserves operational continuity.
What happens to my family home if I become personally liable?
Personal assets including the family home can be exposed through personal guarantees, Director Penalty Notices (for ATO debt), or court orders for insolvent trading liability. The family home is not automatically quarantined. However, spouse ownership (joint or tenants in common), historic mortgage timing, and state-based protections can affect exposure. Early professional advice on asset structuring is critical — but be aware that late-stage transfers are voidable.
Will my employees lose their entitlements?
Employee entitlements (wages, super, leave, redundancy) are priority creditors in any formal insolvency. If the company cannot pay, employees can access the Fair Entitlements Guarantee (FEG) — a Commonwealth scheme that covers most unpaid entitlements except superannuation. In SBR, employee entitlements are protected and paid in full; they are excluded debts and cannot be compromised.
Can suppliers or creditors come after me personally?
Only if you have signed personal guarantees, taken on personal debt, or engaged in insolvent trading. Most supplier debts are company debts only — they stay with the company through insolvency. Personal guarantees are a major exception: if you guaranteed a supplier account, landlord obligation, or equipment finance, personal liability survives company insolvency. Review all guarantees before deciding on a pathway.
Can I just shut the company and walk away?
No. A company cannot simply be "walked away from". To legally end a company, you must either: (1) deregister it (only available for solvent companies with no debts and no outstanding ASIC obligations), (2) liquidate it (a formal insolvency process run by a liquidator), or (3) use SBR/VA to compromise or restructure debts first. Attempting to abandon a company with debts creates serious director exposure and potential phoenix activity allegations.
What if the ATO has threatened to wind up my company?
ATO wind-up applications are serious but not immediate — they typically follow a statutory demand with 21 days to pay or set aside. Receiving a statutory demand is one of the strongest signals to act immediately. Engaging a restructuring practitioner within that window can shift to an SBR appointment before the ATO files the wind-up application. Once a wind-up application is filed, options narrow to court-supervised pathways.
Business Insolvency Glossary — Key Legal Terms Directors Need to Know
Australian insolvency law has a dense vocabulary drawn from the Corporations Act 2001 and decades of case law. Concise definitions of the eleven terms that matter most during insolvency decisions:
- Insolvency (Cash-flow Test)
- The primary Australian legal test for company insolvency under s 95A of the Corporations Act: inability to pay debts as and when they become due and payable. Cash-flow insolvency looks at liquidity and payment capacity, not balance-sheet net worth. A company can be cash-flow insolvent while still having net positive equity.
- Insolvent Trading (s 588G)
- The statutory prohibition on directors allowing their company to incur new debts while the company is insolvent. Directors who breach s 588G can be personally liable for the new debts, plus fines up to $200,000 and criminal prosecution in serious cases. The Insolvent Trading provisions are the primary personal-liability risk directors face during insolvency.
- Safe Harbour (s 588GA)
- Statutory protection available to directors who, after suspecting insolvency, develop a course of action reasonably likely to lead to a better outcome than immediate liquidation. Safe harbour requires genuine turnaround planning, appropriate professional advice, payment of employee entitlements, and tax lodgement compliance. Protects against insolvent trading liability during the turnaround period.
- Statutory Demand
- A formal demand for payment under s 459E of the Corporations Act. A creditor (including the ATO) can serve a statutory demand for debts over $4,000. Failure to pay or apply to set aside within 21 days creates a presumption of insolvency under s 459C, supporting a wind-up application.
- Presumption of Insolvency
- The legal outcome under s 459C where a company's failure to comply with a statutory demand (or other specified events) creates a rebuttable presumption of insolvency in wind-up proceedings. Once this presumption arises, the company must produce evidence of solvency to avoid being wound up.
- Voidable Transaction
- A transaction entered into while the company was insolvent (or that caused insolvency) which a liquidator can recover from the recipient. Categories include unfair preferences (s 588FA), uncommercial transactions (s 588FB), unreasonable director-related transactions (s 588FDA), and unfair loans. Look-back periods range from 6 months to 10 years.
- Unfair Preference
- A payment to a creditor that results in the creditor receiving more than they would in a liquidation. Liquidators can recover unfair preferences from the recipient and redistribute them pro-rata across all unsecured creditors. 6-month look-back for general creditors, 4 years for related parties. A major risk zone during late-stage insolvency.
- Uncommercial Transaction
- A transaction a reasonable person in the company's position would not have entered into, considering benefits, detriments, and alternatives. Selling assets below market, forgiving related-party debts, and paying inflated prices to associates are common examples. 2-year look-back (4 years for related parties).
- Deed of Company Arrangement (DOCA)
- A formal creditor agreement that can emerge from the Voluntary Administration process under Part 5.3A. DOCAs can restructure company debt, set payment terms, and allow trading to continue. Broader and more flexible than SBR but higher cost and complexity. Voted on by creditors at the second VA meeting.
- Fair Entitlements Guarantee (FEG)
- A Commonwealth scheme that pays unpaid employee entitlements (wages, annual leave, long-service leave, payment in lieu of notice, and redundancy pay) when an employer enters formal liquidation. FEG does not cover superannuation — that is recovered separately through the super system and SGC mechanism.
- Phoenix Activity
- The practice of liquidating a company to avoid paying debts and starting a new company that continues the same business. Legal phoenix activity (legitimate business continuation after insolvency with proper governance) is allowed; illegal phoenix activity (deliberate asset stripping to defeat creditors) carries severe criminal and civil penalties under the Illegal Phoenixing Act 2020.
Get Free SBR Eligibility Assessment — You Don't Have to Figure This Out Alone
Over 6,000 Australian businesses have used SBR since 2021. Check if your business is eligible in 2 minutes.
Check Your Eligibility NowFurther Reading — Insolvency, SBR & Director Duties
Business insolvency intersects with director duties, restructuring options, and ATO enforcement. Core adjacent resources:
What is SBR?
Complete guide to Part 5.3B restructuring — eligibility, process, 87% approval rate, and outcomes.
SBR Eligibility Criteria
Pty Ltd, debts under $1M, lodgements current, 7-year rule, and director duty compliance.
Safe Harbour Protection
Section 588GA defence against insolvent trading liability while pursuing restructuring.
Insolvent Trading
Personal liability risks, when the law applies, and how to mitigate exposure.
Director Penalty Notices
21-day response, lockdown vs non-lockdown DPNs, personal director tax exposure.
ATO Debt Help
Payment plans, SBR, liquidation, garnishee, DPN, and enforcement escalation roadmap.
SBR vs Voluntary Administration
Director control, formality, costs, timelines, and when each process fits.
SBR vs Liquidation
Cost, timeline, director control, company survival, and creditor recovery comparison.
SBR vs Informal Workout
When a formal restructuring process outperforms direct creditor negotiation.
Business Insolvency & Small Business Restructuring Frequently Asked Questions
Last updated: